Charitable Remainder Trusts (CRTs) are powerful estate planning tools that allow you to generate lifetime income, claim significant tax breaks, and leave a lasting gift to charity. This guide covers the federal and state laws governing CRTs, highlights key benefits and common pitfalls, and provides practical examples to help you decide if a CRT fits your financial and philanthropic goals.
📜 What Is a Charitable Remainder Trust?
A CRT is an irrevocable trust that splits your asset into two interests:
- An income interest – paid to you (or other non-charitable beneficiaries) for life or a fixed term of up to 20 years.
- A charitable remainder interest – after the income period ends, the remaining assets go to one or more qualified charities of your choice.
Because the charity holds the ultimate remainder interest, the trust qualifies for special tax treatment under federal law, including avoiding capital gains tax when appreciated assets are sold inside the trust.
⚖️ Federal Law Framework
Internal Revenue Code § 664
The statutory heart of CRTs is 26 U.S.C. § 664, which defines the two types of qualified CRTs and sets the rules for their formation, operation, and taxation.
1) Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT)
A CRAT pays a fixed sum certain each year (not less than 5% and not more than 50% of the initial net fair market value of the trust property). This amount does not change, even if the trust’s assets appreciate or depreciate.
- Payout rules: The fixed annuity amount is set when the trust is created and remains constant for the life of the trust.
- No subsequent contributions allowed: Once a CRAT is funded, you generally cannot add more assets to it later.
2) Charitable Remainder Unitrust (CRUT)
A CRUT pays a fixed percentage (again 5%–50%) of the net fair market value of the trust’s assets, revalued annually. As the trust’s value grows, your income grows; if the trust declines in value, income declines accordingly.
- Payout rules: Payments fluctuate with the annual valuation of the trust’s assets.
- Subsequent contributions allowed: You can add more assets to a CRUT after its creation.
Both types must pay the specified amount at least annually and can use a term of years (up to 20 years) or one or more measuring lives as the income period. At least one income beneficiary must be a non-charitable person (e.g., you, your spouse, or another individual).
🧠 Takeaway: Choose a CRAT if you want predictable fixed income. Choose a CRUT if you want income potential to grow with the trust’s assets and the flexibility to add future contributions.
🏛️ Key Federal Requirements
💰 Minimum Charitable Remainder (10% Rule)
IRC § 664(d)(1)(D) and (d)(2)(D) require that the actuarial present value of the charitable remainder interest be at least 10% of the initial net fair market value of all property placed in the trust.
For CRUTs, the 10% requirement applies both at the initial funding and on the date of each subsequent contribution.
This rule prevents donors from choosing a payout rate so high (e.g., 50%) that they would likely leave only a nominal amount to charity.
❌ No Income Tax on the Trust
A CRT is exempt from federal income tax under subtitle A of the Code. However, if the trust earns unrelated business taxable income (UBTI), it is subject to an excise tax equal to the amount of UBTI. For taxable years beginning after December 31, 2006, this excise tax is treated as imposed by chapter 42 of the Code.
📝 Distribution Characterization
When the CRT makes payments to its income beneficiaries, the amounts are characterized as follows:
- First: Ordinary income (to the extent of current and undistributed prior-year ordinary income).
- Second: Capital gain income (to the extent of current and undistributed prior-year capital gain).
- Third: Other income (e.g., tax-exempt interest).
- Fourth: Trust corpus (return of principal).
This ordering rule can be tax-advantageous because capital gains may be “spread” over multiple years rather than recognized all at once.
🔒 Irrevocability
Once established, a CRT is irrevocable. “Once assets are transferred into a CRT, the grantor loses control over them, and the terms of the trust generally cannot be changed.”
📄 Required Governing Instrument
The trust instrument must meet the detailed requirements of Treasury Regulations §§ 1.664-1 through 1.664-4. These regulations cover everything from the definition of “annuity amount” and “unitrust amount” to how the value of the charitable remainder interest is calculated and how to handle distributions to charity.
🗽 State Law Considerations
While federal law governs qualification for tax benefits, state trust law governs administration, fiduciary duties, and enforcement. Below are examples from two major states.
Florida: Florida Trust Code & Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act
Florida has adopted the Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act (UPMIFA) as part of Florida Statutes § 617.2104. This statute applies to institutional funds held for charitable purposes. It requires that in managing and investing an institutional fund, the institution shall consider the charitable purposes of the institution and the purposes of the institutional fund.
For CRT administration in Florida:
- Florida Trust Code (§§ 736.0101–736.0112) applies to express trusts, including charitable trusts.
- The Florida Attorney General has the authority to represent charitable beneficiaries and enforce charitable trusts.
- Practical CRT forms governed by Florida law will include provisions on trustee nomination and succession, trustee powers and compensation, and spendthrift protections.
Key Florida requirement: When a CRT holds real property in Florida, you must comply with Florida’s real property title and recording requirements, especially if the property will be sold or transferred.
New York: Prudent Investor Act (EPTL § 11-2.3)
New York’s Prudent Investor Act, embodied in Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 11-2.3, imposes a duty to invest and manage trust assets as a prudent investor would, considering the purposes, terms, distribution requirements, and other circumstances of the trust.
Key New York provisions for CRTs:
- Power to adjust: Under EPTL § 11-2.3(5), a trustee may adjust between principal and income to achieve a fair total return when traditional trust accounting would produce an inequitable result.
- Acceptance of delegation: EPTL § 11-2.3(c)(3) provides rules for when a trustee delegates investment or management functions.
- Annual registration and fees: New York Codes, Rules and Regulations Part 92.3 provides that charitable remainder trusts are not required to pay a registration fee but must pay an EPTL filing fee when submitting a final report.
🧠 Key difference: Florida has adopted more detailed statutory trust legislation under its Trust Code, while New York relies heavily on judicial doctrines (cy pres, equitable deviation) alongside Prudent Investor Act standards.
💡 Practical Examples: How a CRT Works
Example 1: CRAT for a Business Owner
Maria owns highly appreciated stock worth 200,000. She wants to sell the stock, diversify, and receive lifetime income while avoiding a large capital gains tax bill.
- Maria transfers the stock to a CRAT with a 5% fixed annuity payable to her for 20 years.
- The CRT sells the stock. Because the CRT is tax-exempt, it pays no capital gains tax on the $1.8 million gain.
- Maria receives **
2 million) for 20 years.
- At the end of 20 years, the remaining trust assets (plus any growth) pass to her designated charity.
- Maria claims an immediate income tax deduction for the present value of the charity’s remainder interest (calculated using IRS actuarial tables and the § 7520 rate).
Example 2: CRUT to Diversify and Grow Income
Robert transfers $1 million of low-basis real estate to a CRUT with a 6% unitrust payout to him for life.
- The CRT sells the real estate, paying no capital gains tax at the trust level.
- The trustee reinvests the proceeds into a diversified portfolio.
- Robert receives
1 million). If the portfolio grows to
72,000 (6% of $1.2 million).
- If the portfolio declines, his income declines, but any missed payments are not made up (unless the CRUT is structured as a “NIMCRUT” – see below).
📈 Advanced CRT Variants
1) NIMCRUT (Net Income Make-Up Charitable Remainder Unitrust)
A NIMCRUT pays the lesser of:
- (i) the unitrust percentage amount, or
- (ii) the trust’s actual accounting income for the year.
If income is insufficient in one year, the shortfall goes into a “make-up account” that can be paid out in future years when income exceeds the unitrust percentage.
Best for: Appreciated assets that generate little current income (e.g., raw land, closely held business interests). When the asset is eventually sold, the trust can distribute the “make-up” amount to the beneficiary.
2) Flip CRUT
A “Flip CRUT” begins as a NIMCRUT for a specified period (e.g., until a liquidity event occurs) and then “flips” to a standard CRUT paying a fixed percentage of the trust’s annual value. This hybrid structure allows you to hold illiquid assets during the accumulation phase and then switch to a higher income stream after sale.
3) FLP-CRT (Family Limited Partnership + CRT)
A more advanced strategy combines a Family Limited Partnership (FLP) with a CRT. Business owners transfer interests in the FLP to a CRT, the CRT holds the FLP interests, and the FLP owns operating assets. This can provide valuation discounts (for lack of marketability and minority interest) on the gift to charity, asset protection, and continued family control.
⚠️ Warning: FLP-CRT planning is highly technical and may be challenged by the IRS. Always work with experienced counsel.
🔁 SECURE 2.0 Act: New Opportunities for IRA Owners
The SECURE 2.0 Act (effective beginning in 2023) significantly expanded the ability to use Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) from IRAs to fund CRTs.
- Individuals age 70½ or older may now make a one‑time election (indexed for inflation) to use a QCD to fund:
- A Charitable Remainder Unitrust (CRUT)
- A Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT)
- A Charitable Gift Annuity (CGA)
- The QCD amount is excluded from the donor’s gross income and counts toward the donor’s required minimum distribution (RMD).
- This allows IRA owners to remove lump‑sum IRA distributions from their taxable income while still receiving lifetime payments from the CRT.
In addition, the 10‑year rule under SECURE Act 1.0 (and continued under SECURE 2.0) has renewed interest in using CRTs as IRA beneficiaries to mimic the “stretch IRA” that was formerly available. By naming a CRT as IRA beneficiary, the IRA can pay out over the life of the non‑charitable beneficiary, with the remainder passing to charity.
📋 Qualified Appraisals for Unmarketable Assets
If you contribute unmarketable assets to a CRT – such as a closely held business interest, raw land, or real property – the IRS may require a qualified appraisal from a qualified appraiser.
- The appraisal establishes the fair market value of the asset.
- That value is used to calculate both the donor’s charitable deduction and whether the 10% charitable remainder requirement is satisfied.
- For CRUTs, this requirement applies to initial funding and each subsequent contribution.
🧠 Best practice: Obtain a qualified appraisal before transferring any illiquid asset to a CRT.
🎓 What Are the Tax Benefits?
✅ Immediate Income Tax Deduction
Upon funding the CRT, you may claim an income tax charitable deduction (subject to limitations) for the present value of the charity’s remainder interest. This value is calculated under IRC § 7520 using:
- The IRS discount rate (published monthly),
- The payout rate (5%–50%),
- The life expectancies of the income beneficiaries (or the term of years).
Limitation: The deduction for contributions to a CRT is generally limited to 30% of your adjusted gross income (AGI) for contributions of appreciated property, with a five-year carry‑forward for excess deductions.
✅ Avoid Capital Gains Tax on Appreciated Assets
When a CRT sells appreciated assets, the trust pays no capital gains tax at the federal level. The entire sales proceeds remain in the trust to be reinvested and paid out to you over time. The “built‑in” capital gain is recognized only as payments are distributed to you, according to the four‑tier ordering rule.
✅ Estate Tax Savings
Assets you transfer to a CRT are removed from your gross estate for federal estate tax purposes, provided you retain no prohibited powers or interests over the trust property.
✅ Gift Tax Savings
If you name someone other than your spouse as the income beneficiary, the transfer is treated as a gift of the income interest. However, you may use your annual gift tax exclusion ($19,000 per donee in 2026) or your lifetime gift tax exemption to offset any gift tax liability.
⚠️ Common Pitfalls to Avoid
❌ Pitfall #1: Funding the CRT Too Late
“One common planning mistake occurs when a CRT is established or funded after a binding sale agreement is already in place.” If you have a binding contract to sell appreciated property before creating the CRT, the IRS can deem that you – not the CRT – sold the asset, and you will owe capital gains tax.
❌ Pitfall #2: Failing to Properly Fund the Trust
Trust documents are only half the battle. “Failure to properly fund a trust is consistently cited by estate attorneys as the single most common reason trusts don’t work as intended.” You must retitle assets into the name of the CRT. Otherwise, the trust never owns the property, and you get none of the tax benefits.
❌ Pitfall #3: Payout Rate Set Too High (Violating 10% Rule)
If the present value of the charitable remainder interest falls below 10% of the initial trust value, the entire trust fails to qualify as a CRT. Your charitable deduction is disallowed, and the trust may be subject to regular income tax.
❌ Pitfall #4: Unrelated Business Taxable Income (UBTI)
If a CRT earns UBTI (e.g., from debt‑financed real estate or an active trade or business), it is subject to excise tax equal to the full amount of UBTI. Repeated UBTI could cause the IRS to revoke the trust’s CRT status.
❌ Pitfall #5: Using a CRT as Part of an Abusive Tax Scheme
The IRS has warned against “abusive transactions that attempt to use a section 664 charitable remainder trust to convert appreciated assets into cash while avoiding tax on the gain.” Certain CRAT promotion schemes have been included on the IRS “Dirty Dozen” list of tax scams.
❌ Pitfall #6: Loss of Control
The irrevocable nature of a CRT is its greatest strength – and its greatest risk. Once assets are transferred, you cannot:
- Change the payout rate;
- Change the income beneficiaries (except in limited circumstances);
- Terminate the trust early without incurring severe tax penalties;
- Take back the principal.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I be the trustee of my own CRT?
A: Yes, you can act as trustee of a CRT, but with important caveats: If you retain the power to control investments or distributions, the trust may be includible in your gross estate for estate tax purposes. For illiquid assets, the IRS may require an independent trustee to value unmarketable assets.
Q: Can I name multiple charities?
A: Yes, you can name one or more qualified charitable organizations (described in IRC § 170(c)). You can even retain the right to change the charitable beneficiary during your lifetime.
Q: What if I want to leave the remainder to a donor‑advised fund (DAF)?
A: Under current law, a DAF may qualify as a charitable beneficiary of a CRT, but careful drafting is required to ensure the DAF meets the definition of a “public charity” under IRC § 170(b)(1)(A).
Q: What happens to the trust if all income beneficiaries die before the term ends?
A: The trust terminates, and the remainder passes immediately to the designated charity.
Q: Can a CRT own life insurance?
A: Generally, no. Owning life insurance inside a CRT can generate UBTI if the policy is considered debt‑financed. However, limited exceptions exist.
📌 Final Takeaways
| 👍 Advantages | 👎 Disadvantages / Risks |
| Avoid capital gains tax on appreciated assets | Irrevocable – you cannot change your mind or take assets back |
| Receive lifetime income stream (fixed or variable) | Complex to draft and requires ongoing administration |
| Immediate income tax deduction (30% AGI limit, 5‑year carry‑forward) | 10% charitable remainder requirement can be difficult to satisfy |
| Remove assets from your gross estate (estate tax savings) | Potential excise tax if trust earns UBTI |
| Support charitable causes you care about | Must pay annual amounts (5%–50%) – no skipping payments |
| Contribute using IRA QCDs (SECURE 2.0) – exclude distributions from income | Qualified appraisal required for illiquid assets |
| Payout as low as 5% allows trust assets to continue growing tax‑free | Poor trust performance can reduce your income |
📅 Recent Developments & Outlook
- SECURE 2.0 (2023) expanded QCDs to CRTs, opening powerful planning for IRA owners.
- Treasury Regulations continue to evolve, with proposed regulations addressing abusive CRT transactions and valuation of unmarketable assets.
- Several states have modernized their trust codes (e.g., Florida’s UPMIFA, New York’s Prudent Investor Act) to provide clearer rules for CRT administration.
🧠 Remember: A Charitable Remainder Trust is not for everyone. It works best for individuals with highly appreciated assets who want both current income and charitable giving, and who can accept the permanent loss of access to the underlying principal.
#CharitableRemainderTrust #CRT #CRAT #CRUT #NIMCRUT #FlipCRUT #SecureAct2 #EstatePlanning #TaxPlanning #CharitableGiving #QualifiedCharitableDistribution #IRASection664 #Section7520 #AvoidCapitalGains #PlannedGiving #Philanthropy #WealthManagement #FamilyLimitedPartnership #FLPCRT #PrudentInvestorAct #FloridaTrustCode #NewYorkEPTL #IRSRegulations
🔔 Legal Disclosure
DISCLOSURE: Tax laws, regulations, and judicial interpretations change frequently. The information in this post is based on federal law as codified in the Internal Revenue Code (including 26 U.S.C. § 664, § 170, § 2055, § 2522, and § 7520) and Treasury Regulations (including 26 CFR §§ 1.664‑1 to 1.664‑4, 1.170A‑6) as of May 12, 2026, along with the state laws of Florida and New York as examples. State laws vary significantly; you must consult a qualified attorney familiar with the laws of your specific state. This post does not constitute legal or tax advice and does not create an attorney‑client relationship. You should not rely on this information without obtaining independent professional advice tailored to your specific circumstances.
For specific questions about Charitable Remainder Trusts or to determine whether a CRT is right for you, please contact: Alan Goldstein
Was this helpful?
0 / 0